|
It
is widely known that a bonsai can be described as having form
and style.
The form
describes the shape of the trunk (sometimes also referred to as
its style); the form might be informal upright, cascade
or broom for instance.
The bonsai
style is the term used to describe the manner in which
the tree is styled and presented; a classical 'Japanese' style
with horizontal branching as one would expect a Pine to be or
a naturalistic style, showing branching one would expect of a
deciduous tree.
A third equally
important descriptive term might be considered is the view
at which the tree is seen. Is the tree seen from up close, as
if standing at its base looking upward (short view) or at a distance
as though seen on the horizon (the long view)?
Why
is establishing the view important?
Trees seen
in the near view exhibit much different features to those seen
from afar; trunk taper, branching, foliage density, even the appearance
of any deadwood is entirely different.
If near view and far view features appear on the same tree, a
confusing image is presented to the viewer and the ideal presentation
of the tree is lost.
Near
View Trees
Near
view trees are seen as though standing at their base looking upwards
into the branches.
 
Swamp
Cypress at Tatton Park, UK. On the left seen from the long view,
on the right from the near view.
This
is the view that is more popularly described for bonsai.
The trunk at the base (beside which the viewer stands) is the
widest point and can appear to be massive. Looking upwards, perspective
means that the trunk thins as the eye travels up the trunk; this
means that the top of the trunk, which is furthest from the viewer,
is very narrow in comparison to the base.
Even on a fairly uniform trunk, seen from below the perspective
will create the illusion of taper. The greater the amount of taper
between the base of the trunk and its top, the more the tree
appears to tower over the viewer. In terms of bonsai, a trunk
ratio of 6:1 or greater (height: trunk diameter) is used to convey
an image of a tree towering over the viewer. The lower the ratio,
the greater and more severe the image becomes.
Far
View Trees
Far view trees are seen as though they are on the horizon in a
landscape.

Scots
Pines seen in Norfolk UK, in the long view
This
view is commonly used for group plantings and literati form trees
but it can be used as equally for any form such as informal upright
or broom bonsai.
The base and the top of the trunk are seen from the same perspective;
that is, they are seen naturally. The trunk does naturally taper
from its widest point at the base up to its thinnest point in
the apex. However, unlike a trunk seen in the near view, the trunk
taper is less severe as the perspective does not 'add' the illusion
of taper.
One
of the same Scots Pines seen from below in the near view.
The severely tapered trunk of the tree seen from its base (near
view) loses much of its taper when seen from a distance.
In terms of bonsai, a ratio of 6:1 or less (anything up to 15:1)
is used to convey an image of a tree seen at a distance.
Trunk
taper defines the view
When styling
a tree for bonsai, the shape and movement of a trunk define the
form of the bonsai. That is whether it will be an informal upright,
a cascade or formal upright.
In the same way, the taper of the trunk defines the view of the
bonsai.
A well-tapered trunk with a trunk height to trunk diameter ratio
of approximately 6:1 or less is suitable for a bonsai in the near
view.
A trunk with slow/slight taper with a height to diameter ratio
of 6:1 or more will be suitable for a bonsai in the far view.
There are
subtle differences when styling trees of one view or another.
A well-designed bonsai will reflect the view at which it is seen
throughout the styling process, from the structure of its branching
to the choice of the final pot. Mixing near-view and far-view
characteristics will produce a confused image of a tree.
Near
View Characteristics
A tree in
the near view will have the following characteristics;
In this (near) view, the branches will appear to be very wide.
Standing at the base of a tree, the branches reach a long way
to the left and the right; an approximate foliage width (at the
base) of 2/3 the height of tree's height is appropriate for an
informal upright design.
As the branches are seen from the same perspective as the well-tapered
trunk, the branches should also diminish noticeably in size the
higher up the trunk they are. The first branches will be long
and thick, the uppermost branches short and thin. This creates
a foliage mass that is overall triangular. Create branches of
similar thickness and length on a heavily tapered trunk and the
perspectives are a mixed up and will not look satisfactory.
Seen from below in the near view, the foliage mass is dense and
heavy. Little light is able to penetrate through the branches.
Deadwood features should be more heavily grained as they are seen
closer up (in the near view) it should be possible to see that
natural deadwood (jins and shari) are not just a smooth expanse
of white wood.

Cedrus
libani at Tatton Park with light branching, less dense branching;
negative space is evident.

The
same branches seen from below are very dense
Far
View Characteristics
A tree in
the far view will have the following characteristics;
The branching appears a more natural width. Approximately 1/3
the overall height of the tree for an informal upright design.
From this far view, the branching is seen at a distance and is
more natural. The branches from base to top of the trunk have
less difference in thickness and are of more similar width; the
familiar scalene triangle is less pronounced or even absent. (Note
that the lower branches should still be longer and thicker than
those at the top, however, there should be less exaggeration than
when seen from the near view perspective).
The foliage canopy should be lighter. At a distance, the mass
of foliage should be broken up with negative space (areas without
foliage).
Deadwood features have less detail; if the viewer is to be made
to believe that the tree is a distance away, highly detailed jin
and shari should not be visible.
Bonsai in the far view should be planted in shallower but wider
pots that create an impression of a landscape.
Why
is it necessary to establish the view at all?
Many of the
bonsai rules, or more properly, guidelines, are aimed at producing
an image of a tree as seen from below (in the near view). This
can dictate a trunk height to diameter of 6:1 or less, heavy lower
branching and lighter branching in the apex and a foliage mass
that forms a triangular shape.
But, in trying to create a more natural, realistic bonsai, one
can also take a more natural view of a tree. That is, as seen
from a distance where the rules of perspective have less influence
on the overall design.
The majority of trees, both young and old, do not have massively
tapered trunks; in fact the majority of old trees we see in our
day-to-day lives have trunks with quite slow taper.
However,
to portray a natural tree seen from a distance, one also has to
reflect the natural characteristics of a tree seen from a distance.
Using near view characteristics on a slow tapering tree will very
often just produce a bonsai that simply looks very young and immature
instead of an image of an old tree seen on the horizon.
Finally.....
In writing
this article I have given two extremes by way of explanation;
a tree that is seen from its base and a tree that is seen in
the distance. There is no reason why a tree has to be strictly
one or the other; there are a range of views in between. The range
and subtlety of these characteristics should therefore differ
accordingly.
The trunk
height to trunk diameter ratio of 6:1 that is often spoken of,
is a guideline. Material that has pronounced trunk taper but
has a ratio greater than 6:1 is still suitable for bonsai, just
not in the near view.
Whether it
is the slow, subtle taper of a tree seen faraway or the heavy,
abrupt taper of a tree seen close-up, all bonsai should have
trunks with a degree of taper. A bonsai without taper will
always look like a young tree!
|